By Heidi Macomber · July 9, 2026 (updated July 28, 2026)

Pricing your menu before you have sales data can feel like a shot in the dark, but it doesn’t have to be. Almost every new owner feels some uncertainty about setting prices at this stage, and it is normal to worry about getting it wrong. This five-step process is designed to help you avoid common mistakes and set your prices with more confidence before opening.

At the very beginning, there are no past sales to light the way. While it might feel like you’re guessing, these steps will give you a clear direction forward.

Step 1. Cost every recipe first

Before you even think about setting prices, break down the cost of every dish on your menu. Count every ingredient per serving, factor in any trim or waste, and don’t forget the hidden costs from sub-recipes like house-made sauces or stocks. This number is the bedrock for everything that follows, so take your time and get it right.

Step 2. Pick a target food cost percentage for the concept

The right food cost percentage is unique to your business. A quick-service spot with a tight menu might shoot for 28-32%, while a full-service restaurant with more variety and labor could land closer to 32-38%. To find your sweet spot, do a quick gut check: consider your menu’s complexity, your style of service, and what similar spots nearby are charging. If you’re using premium ingredients or serving up generous portions, you might want to aim a bit higher. Choose a percentage that truly fits your concept, not just what everyone else is doing.

Step 3. Calculate the suggested price

Suggested price = Cost per portion ÷ Target food cost percentage

If a dish costs $3.50 to make and your target food cost is 30 percent, your suggested price comes out to $11.67. Feel free to round up to $11.75 or $12, whichever fits best with the rest of your menu.

Step 4. Check it against the market being entered

Once you have your suggested prices, take a look at what similar places nearby are charging for comparable dishes, not just their overall menu. Start by browsing competitors’ menus online or through delivery apps. If you can, visit a few local spots to see portion sizes and presentation up close. Chat with industry peers or ask your suppliers about typical price ranges. If your prices are much higher or lower, dig into the reasons before opening. Maybe your portions are more generous, or your food cost target is tighter than it needs to be. The key is to understand your pricing, not just copy someone else’s numbers.

Step 5. Build in room to adjust early

In your first weeks of sales, you’ll learn things that spreadsheets can’t show--like which dishes people actually buy, which ones don’t sell, and how much time each plate really takes. Plan to review your prices after the first month, rather than treating your opening prices as set in stone. Making small changes early is much easier than raising prices a lot later, after customers get used to certain numbers.

Percy Plate can handle steps one through three for you once your recipes are costed. That gives you more time to focus on steps four and five: getting out in your community and paying attention to what’s happening. Setyour menu prices today and start with more confidence.

Related Guides

Stop guessing what your dishes cost.

Percy Plate calculates recipe costs, menu prices, and FDA-compliant labels for food businesses. Free to start.

Create your free account

View this article in the app: https://percyplate.com/blog/how-to-price-your-first-menu-before-you-open